Friday, May 18, 2012

A Beginning Poet's Insider Guide to "Show vs Tell Part 1

PART ONE: TIME

First thing a writer must understand is that the concept of show vs. tell is different for Poetry than it is for short stories or novels. Not so much that they become totally different concepts, but enough to say they are like two different species of dog. Sure, theyre both dogs, but a Great Dane needs different care than a Jack Russell Terrier.

Time in ones life

Several years ago I was in a creative writing class that had a difficult time thinking in metaphors. I was, in turn, having a hard time sharing my thoughts on the subject. It was when I was listening to the radio on the way to class that a spark hit my brain, like it did Frankensteins monster.

I was listening to Billy Joels Piano Man, which is full of Imagery, and I was inspired by how he showed age. Ins tead of saying he was in his twenties or some other such generality or even a specific age, he wrote: When I wore a younger man's clothes

Heres the difference. Telling is saying an age or age category, like 22 or in his twenties. Showing is giving us this image of a man in his youth.

I toyed with this idea for a while and came up with this line, When she first learned the difference between noun and pronoun which gives the impression of early school-age.

Then I also came up with this line (which is from the same poem): As she became armed with drivers license, keys and immortality leads the reader to a teenage image.

Passage of time

Remember I said I was inspired? After having tried those two images, I decided to try something a bit different within the realm of time. I wanted to show the passage of time as well as showing age and I came up with this line (also from the same poem): One day she woke to find the pages of forty calendars litterin g the floor at her feet, like confetti.

This line not only indicates the approximate age of the woman but also shows some time has passed since the last stanza.

Other examples of time images

I was exploring further to find more examples and found these in Literature: An Introduction to Reading and Writing by Edgar V. Roberts and Henry E. Jacobs. (The poems page location will be found in parenthesis after the excerpt.)

Passage of time

Sonnets from the Portuguese: Number 14 by Elizabeth Barrett Browning

A creature might forget to weep, who bore thy comfort long, (704)

A Time Past by Denise Levertov

those wooden steps are gone now, decayed (713)

Time of day

Preludes by T.S. Elliot

Burnt-out ends of smoky days. (707)

This is not to say that any time you want to indicate time in your Poetry you need to use an image instead of just stating it. As with most things, this will depend on your own unique style and the poem you happen to be working on at the time.

2006 Holly Bliss. All Rights Reserved. This document may be freely redistributed in its unedited form and on the condition that all copyright references are kept intact along with the hyperlinked URLs.

About the Author: Using her writing as paint on the canvas of her life, Holly Bliss is an eclectic writer, newsletter editor and an author on http://www.Writing.Com/ which is a site for Poetry.


Author:: Holly Bliss
Keywords:: Poetry, Poet's, Beginning, Guide, show versus tell, Beginners, how to, How-to, Poets, Imagery
Post by History of the Computer | Computer safety tips

No comments:

Post a Comment